Religion in Early Virginia
- Law mandated Virginians worship in the Anglican Church
- Church supported by tax dollars
- Line between religious and civil authority blurred
- Struggle for religious freedom paralleled struggle for political independence
- Virginians not tolerant of non-Christian religions
- White women were primary guardians of family religious life
Colonists supported by tradition of established church
In a stark new world, Virginia's English colonists were supported by an ancient and familiar tradition – the established church. The law of the land from 1624 mandated that white Virginians worship in the Anglican church (Church of England) and support its upkeep with their taxes. Where religion was an integral part of everyday life in Virginia, the lines blurred between religious and civil authority. Virginia gentlemen, who supported establishment but disliked centralized church authority, gained control of parish vestries and county courts to secure their power over religious matters.
Protestant sects resented legal restrictions placed on them
Despite establishment, the religious life of white Virginians was not without diversity. Dissenters from many Protestant sects had settled in the colony from early on – and had long resented the legal restrictions placed on their own practice of religion. Finally, after about 1750, evangelical Christians precipitated a struggle for religious freedom parallel to and often reciprocal with the wider struggle for political independence.
Anglicans mistrusted religious views of Native Americans and Africans
Although Anglicans tolerated Protestant dissenters, they found the traditional religious views of Native Americans and Africans beyond sanction. But English colonists made only fitful and often grudging efforts to bring blacks and Indians into the established church. The Powhatans and Indians further inland proved resistant to Christianity. For blacks, the oppression of slavery inevitably forced them to abandon a purely African world view. Still, they did not come to Christianity in great numbers until evangelicals began gathering converts of both races after the mid-18th century. Although some blacks and whites forged bonds through their shared evangelical experience, Virginia's celebrated statute for religious freedom would have only superficial meaning for African Americans until after the Civil War.
Anglican faith was a private family affair
The Anglican gentry in Virginia long had a reputation for shallow faith and attendance at church born more of habit and a desire for social contact than piety or zeal. Historians have begun to reevaluate this oversimplified view. They now characterize many of Virginia's elite as sincere adherents to a moderate faith that nonetheless provided a standard for judgment. Faith was ultimately a private and family affair. Reflections on a minister's sermons, for example, were discussed within the family group or recorded in diaries, such as those of William Byrd II and John Blair of Williamsburg.
The pervasiveness of religion in 18th-century life inspired the motifs used in the design of some household furnishings. Inscriptions on the pot pictured here encouraged the hostess, as she poured coffee, to "keep her conversation as becometh the lord" and her company to remember the comforting words of the twenty-third psalm, "the lord is my Shepherd I shall not want."
Anglican parishes included gentry and middling class
Recent research indicates that small planters and their families made up the bulk of the congregations in Anglican churches and that these colonists held values similar to those of their betters. While accepting disparity in social rank, they came to expect a certain civility and recognition from the gentry that likely extended to the parish church and churchyard.
Slaves drawn to Evangelical Christianity
The seeds of faith planted in Anglican homes and churches often lay dormant under routine worship and complacency, but later flourished under the influence of evangelical preachers. These men remodeled familiar biblical themes into a compelling message of spiritual renewal and of a personal God who intervened in human affairs. Slaves in unprecedented numbers were drawn to evangelical Christianity, particularly the Baptist sect.
Evangelicals aligned with Revolutionaries to loosen stronghold of Anglican Church
After the mid-18th century, evangelical Christians (Baptists, Presbyterians, and Methodists) challenged the establishment's discriminatory practices by flouting licensing laws and refusing to be restricted to particular meetinghouses or locales. As the Revolution approached, they formed an unlikely partnership with apostles of the Enlightenment among the Revolutionary generation. Both were bent upon disestablishing the Anglican church in Virginia.
Religious revolution mostly peaceful
The diversification of religion in Virginia up to and through the Revolutionary period was relatively peaceful. Conflicts did occur. Anglican agents sometimes forcibly broke up evangelical meetings in the 1770s, and the sight of Baptist ministers preaching from their jail cells galvanized James Madison to give full support to disestablishment. But it seems as if the very multiplicity of religious groups in Virginia (and America) precluded the religious persecutions and sectarian warfare that had plagued England and the rest of Europe for centuries. Virginians proved to be less tolerant of non-Christian faiths, however. Most notably, slavery constituted a form of violence that deprived Africans of their traditional religious systems.
Native Americans resisted conversion to Christianity
Native Americans clashed with colonists not only over land but in resisting conversion to the Christian faith. As settlers pushed back the Indians and as Anglican parishes spread out over Virginia, the gentry were able to gain control of the established church on the local and county levels as well as in the colonial legislature. Anglican elites proved to be tough opponents to evangelical Christians and the Revolutionary leaders who joined them in supporting disestablishment. African Americans also made common cause with the evangelicals after 1750. Before that time, few blacks had joined the Christian fold. In the 17th century, small numbers of slaves had recognized that they could gain their freedom through baptism, but the General Assembly closed this loophole in 1667. Over the next century, most slave owners and Anglican ministers ignored the spiritual lives of African Americans.
Virginia gentry controlled religious matters
Throughout the colonial period, the established church was supported and reinforced by other formal and informal institutions. Virginia lacked a bishop. Hence, control of religious matters was largely left in the hands of local institutions dominated by the gentry. Vestrymen became the dominant influence on church affairs by the end of the 17th century. They paid the clergy, built and repaired church buildings, and provided support for the needy. Justices of the peace, sitting on the bench of county courts, heard cases having to do with attendance at Anglican church services, illegitimacy, adultery, and other moral offenses. In consolidating control over civil and religious matters on all levels, the leading men of the county further enhanced their power, and at the same time imparted their authority to the church.
Established Church protected by Virginia laws
Virginia's General Assembly protected the established church in law. It enforced laws that penalized dissenters: for example, requiring all officeholders to be Anglican. The legislature also exercised authority over such matters as the creation of new parishes and the setting of ministers' salaries. It was in the legislature that the battle over disestablishment was waged and eventually won, but informal institutions also supported the religious lives of Anglicans and dissenters alike.
Families transmitted values and religious teachings. Reflecting the evolution of family relationships, by the mid-18th century, white women had become the primary guardians of the religious lives of their families. For dissenters, itinerant preachers and local congregations played an important role in affirming their faith.